Home / Articles / Boulderganic / Boulderganic /  A batty battle
. . . . . . .
Give Through iGivefirst
Thursday, May 9,2013

A batty battle

Local, federal agencies accused of 'caving' to special interests

By Cecelia Gilboy
Photo courtesy of the City of Boulder OSMP
A closed cave in the Flatirons

Near dark iron gates that cover cave openings in the Flatirons, a sign explains that the caves have been closed because white-nose syndrome has already killed more than 5 million bats. Local author and cave expert Richard Rhinehart informed the City of Boulder’s Open Space and Mountain Parks (OSMP) office of an inaccuracy on the signs. But the money had already been spent, he says, on the sign and the ornate gate with iron-wrought bat silhouettes. He guesses it’s one reason why Boulder won’t lift its year-round cave closures, even as recent research has persuaded the U.S. Forest Service to lift its closures. The differing policies have sparked a debate about who has the facts, who listens to whom and who’s really protecting bats. Both recreationists and conservationists are questioning whether Boulder’s closures can stop the spread of the disease.

White-nose syndrome is caused by a fungus. Infected bats wake up from hibernation, disturbed by the fungus growing on their snouts. Fidgeting and flying around, they burn through their calorie reserves. In the cold winter, with no food available, they starve to death.

Believing that the fungal spores could be transmitted on human boots and caving gear, Boulder and the Forest Service both initiated year-round cave closures to slow the spores’ westward march in 2010.

“When white-nose syndrome made that big jump to Oklahoma, that concerned a lot of us in the West,” says Tina Jackson, species conservation coordinator at Colorado Parks and Wildlife.

Boulder’s caves will remain closed, according to a recent OSMP press release, along with nearby crags popular with rock climbers. Climbers respect the closures, says Matt Samet of the Flatirons Climbing Council, because they recognize OSMP’s need to protect species in the Flatirons.

The closures protect habitat for a declining bat species, says Will Keeley, wildlife biologist at OSMP. The OSMP press release states that the closures protect species considered sensitive by the Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management (BLM) — especially due to white-nose syndrome.

But the Forest Service and BLM aren’t keeping the public out of their caves or nearby climbing areas.

“Boulder is making this decision on their own,” says Paul Ryan, vice chair of the National Speleological Society’s Colorado Grotto.

This summer, the Forest Service will re-open caves to the general public, says Steve Lenzo, the Forest Service line officer representative on cave management decisions in the Rocky Mountain region. Permits will still be required for caves heavily used by sensitive bats. The spores still haven’t crossed the Great Plains toward the Rockies, he says, and may not ever make it as far as Colorado.

The fungus can survive only under specific temperature and humidity conditions, Jackson explains. So her agency is collecting data on microclimates in caves.

“The Forest Service cave closures did impact our ability to do internal work,” she says. But last summer, the Forest Service began allowing researchers and “organized” cavers to enter its caves.

Cavers also help with research, Lenzo says.

“We don’t have the resources to monitor every cave,” he says.

The new Forest Service plan, which proposes opening caves to all of the public, will require observations from cavers.

“The caving community can be an early warning system,” Lenzo says. “They were pleased with the decision.”

The relationship between Forest Service staff and cavers has been strained since the 2010 cave closures, according to Rhinehart and Derek Bristol, chair of the Colorado Cave Survey.

“There will probably be some lingering tension,” Bristol says. “With the new adaptive management plan, we can try to repair the relationship.”

But the rekindled relationship doesn’t please everyone.

“I think [the new plan] had to do with direct pressure from the caving community,” says Mollie Matteson, conservation advocate at the Center for Biological Diversity. Her nonprofit is filing an appeal against the recent Forest Service decision, arguing that it favors recreationists over bats.

“We’re not just recreationists,” Ryan says. Cavers are driven by a desire to explore hidden ecosystems, he says, to better understand and preserve them.

Matteson says that cavers never stopped caving, despite the closures.

“The Forest Service has decided that since some people break the law, just to get rid of the law,” she says.


Spring Cave in the White River National Forest | Photo by Richard Rhinehart

But she explains that bat protection is critical. Without bats to devour insects, farms are in trouble. And the deadly spores can piggy-back on cavers — it’s probably how they hitched from Europe to New York in 2006.

Cavers dispute their role in spreading the disease, and Bristol calls it a politically charged issue.

Matteson says the claim that cavers wouldn’t spread the fungus to other caves is “inconceivable.” Laboratory work found spores on a caver’s gear, but that didn’t prove that trudging a couple spores into another cave would infect it, Rhinehart says.

The main transmission is bat-to-bat, agree the cavers, scientists and Matteson.

“But the risk [of human transmission] is there, and to dismiss it is pretty self-serving,” Matteson argues.

The risk is mitigated, Lenzo says, by the decontamination procedures that will be required.

“We’re taking no chances with cave equipment,” he says.

Cavers say the decontamination procedures have already been adopted. Matteson is dubious, she says, because she’s heard how time-consuming they are. She says she doesn’t believe decontamination — or anything else — will stop the inevitable: The fungus is coming.

“This is about buying time,” she says, referring to the time needed for scientists to race to find a cure. “We recommend blanket closures. We think the Forest Service should go back to the way it was three years ago.”

Cavers aren’t surprised by the nonprofit’s reaction. They have clashed with the Center for Biological Diversity before.

“We share the angle of wanting to see as much done as possible to help bats,” Bristol says. “We just have different opinions about the best way to accomplish that.”

Matteson acknowledges that the disease hasn’t spread past Oklahoma.

“Maybe that’s because what they did [by closing caves] is working,” she says.

But without the regional closures, Boulder can’t buy time for its local bats alone.

“I applaud Boulder’s protective policy toward bats,” she says. “But if all the caves on Forest Service land and BLM land are open, then it’s not going to be protective for one little land unit to have caves closed.”

Boulder’s bubble of closures can be attributed to the nonprofit Matteson works for, the Center for Biological Diversity, according to Ryan and Rhinehart. When the cave closures became year-round in 2010, Rhinehart contacted Boulder Open Space. He says OSMP staff ended their discussions by reciting quotes from the center’s press releases.

“They’re big admirers of the Center for Biological Diversity,” he says of Boulder Open Space staff.

And the center recommends buffers.

Boulder is still following its direction, Ryan says. If you enter a buffer around a cave in Boulder, you face jail time.

Elsewhere in Colorado, most caves are expected to be open to the public this summer — if the Forest Service policy isn’t changed by the lawsuit from the Center for Biological Diversity.

Respond: letters@boulderweekly.com



  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
No Registration Required
I have found this article very exciting. Do you have any others on this topic? I am also sending it to my friend to enjoy your writing style. Thanks
cheapest locksmith in tucson


I am usually to blogging and i genuinely appreciate your content regularly. This content has truly peaks my interest. I will bookmark your web site and maintain checking achievable details.


This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information... votre


Very useful post. This is my first time i visit here. I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. Really its great article. Keep it up. Can you get rid of cellulite


Fantastic blog! Do you have any tips and hints for aspiring writers? I’m planning to start my own website soon but I’m a little lost on everything. Would you propose starting with a free platform like WordPress or go for a paid option? There are so many options out there that I’m completely overwhelmed .. Any suggestions? Many thanks! identity mgmt systems


I am definitely enjoying your website. You definitely have some great insight and great stories. next post


Thanks for the blog loaded with so many information. Stopping by your blog helped me to get what I was looking for. mehr Bücher


Thanks for your post. I’ve been thinking about writing a very comparable post over the last couple of weeks, I’ll probably keep it short and sweet and link to this instead if thats cool. Thanks. HD Wallpapers


Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. rebelmouse.com/truthfatburningfoodsreview


very interesting post.this is my first time visit here.i found so mmany interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion..thanks for the post! happy fathers day


Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking. check this link right here now



Karl Lagerfeld, Germany famous fashion designer,Christian Louboutin Shoes was born in 1933 in Hamburg.Speaking of Karl Lagerfeld,Christian Louboutin Outlet head first is the artistic director of Chanel's trademark expression forever,Roger Vivier Shoes wearing dark glasses,and holding a catch fan,Roger Vivier Outlet the back of the head with pigtails,is this eternal sunglasses white hair long braid was actually occupying commanding point of fashion. People refer to him as the fashion of Julius Caesar, and Galeries Lafayette.He's always like eat ginseng as energetic,Kate Spade Outlet fluent in German,English,French,Italian,and witty,Kate Spade Handbags his love of traditional,and look forward to the future,dubbed by the media representatives of the UGG Outlet contemporary renaissance.Comments in November 2013 for alleged discrimination against fat had been France women's group sued.Karl lagerfeld every year Cheap UGG Boots for the production of eight series of Chanel clothing,including ready-to-wear and haute couture,Michael Kors Outlet for the production of 5 series, Fendi also do design for his own brand. He this kind of super ability to his global lead in the fashion industry.He is also Michael Kors Handbags a famous photographer.

He not only for Chanel shooting pictures and product catalogue,also held the exhibition of his own.As a knowledge of English,French,German and Italian,he is not willing to miss the publishing industry also.In Paris he Rue Lille on opened a bookstore called 7 l,Michael Kors Outlet books published by the topic he is interested in all kinds of fields, including fashion,photography,literature,Michael Kors Outlet Online advertising,music,newspaper,mythology, illustration,humor works and buildings.However,one of the most popular is unabashed Lagerfeld himself Michael Kors Outlet published in 2002 "Karl unabashed Lagerfeld guide to lose weight.In September 1938,was born in Hamburg,Germany.Karl,Michael Kors Handbags who was born in 1938,but various evidence that he is actually understates his 5 years old! Karl lagerfeld's father was selling condensed milk businessman,Michael Kors Outlet mother is lingerie salesman. 14 years old when his family moved to Paris, and the finished school.

In 1954,he received champion of Michael Kors Wallets the fashion design award wool jacket.

In 1955,selected by judges Pierre Balmain fashion design award for Assistant, studying under its brand.Chanel Outlet

In 1958,as the fashion designer Jean Patou. Five years after the official departure of freelance.Chanel Handbags

In 1964, he became Chloe Designer, brand positioning in the classical-romantic style.

In October 1972, Karl Lagerfeld designed the Chloe spring/summer 1973 collection was a success,Cheap Oakley Sunglasses and became headline news. Again in 1992 as the brand's designer.Oakley Sunglasses In 1965,has been in charge of design for the FENDI brand,while famous double f FENDI logo is from the hand of Karl.

Oakley Outlet Carl dramatic design Fendi (FENDI) brand clothing received worldwide attention and praise in the fashion,Ray Ban Sunglasses FENDI to Haute Couture line positions.

In 1983,he became designer CHANEL brand,Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses generally are not optimistic about the situation in the outside world, successf ully resurrect brand,Ray Ban Outlet

CHANEL became one of the most profitable fashion brands in the world. Carl perfect essence of refined elegance of Coco Chanel,Louis Vuitton Outlet Online modified,retaining loyal customer,while moderation into the sport,rock elements,attracting a young,Louis Vuitton Handbags consummate skill and Haute Couture flourish, Chanel leads a pair of successful Louis Vuitton Outlet postwar modern and elegant stay. While button square Desrues Lemari Louis Vuitton Outlet Online,embroidery, feather ornaments Fang Fang Lesage Massaro, hat, shoe Fang Fang Michel Goossens and floral,Louis Vuitton Outlet Stores gold and silver ornaments Fang Fang Guillet one by one in the Pocket.

In 1984, the personal name brand Karl Lagerfeld, in his own brand,Gucci Outlet Karl full embodiment of the characteristics: fit,Gucci Shoes skinny,short sleeve outwards along cutting lines,classical style Tiffany Outlet combined with the sentiment on the streets,forming a lot of innovation.

In 1987 for branding purposes,began his photographic career,Tiffany Jewellery after CHANEL,FENDI and most taken by its namesake brand advertising. Photography and fashion magazines have many times together.

Ed Hardy Clothing In November 2004, Carl and Sweden leading fast fashion brand M work,Ed Hardy Outlet the launch of the Karl M limited edition fashion,Cheap Jordans is considered sold out after 2 days.

On December 8,2006,Carr announced the launch of brands under Air Jordan the same name brand k Karl Lagerfeld,Coach Factory Outlet Karl Lagerfeld positioning young recreational fashion,Coach Outlet Store Online menswear Ladieswear,churning out of Tee and jeans.

In October 2007, the FENDI at the great wall of China organized the press conference,Coach Purse kaercheng the first designer of the wall held a press conference.Coach Outlet June 10, 2008, ~9 7th,Versailles Karl Lagerfeld launched the Sun Coach Outlet Online in the light of the Palace of Versailles photography exhibition, a totally original perspective,Coach Outlet Store Online through light and shadow to capture brilliant Coach Factory interpretation of Versailles unique cultural and historical heritage.

In 2008,France road safety under the invitation of the Minister,Coach Factory Outlet Online outside his fluorescent yellow clothes wears a dark suit and Coach Outlet wearing his favourite fingerless black gloves, and trademark black sunglasses,Coach Factory Outlet the campaign slogan is: it's yellow, it's ugly, and it doesn't fit anything,Burberry Handbags but it does protect your life. He also boarded the French dictionary Le Petit Larousse,Burberry Outlet (the Larousse encyclopedia dictionary) cover of the 2009 Edition.

Michael Kors Outlet Germany introduced the teddy bear shape being similar to Carr's Michael Kors Store limited-edition Teddy bear. With black sunglasses,Coach Factory dark black suits with white striped shirt and thin black tie,as well as with KL bright diamond logo waistband.Coach Outlets Carl was involved in the design of artificial islands luxury Isla Moda.

Talking about his pet cat, the fashion guru is in full flight, he said my cat is like a walk in the Park, frolicking in the garden or enjoy shopping. The cat has a dedicated maid caring for each week are full-time doctors to cut their nails. She is very naughty and always laugh by the maid to take care of her.


I read that Post and got it fine and informative. Please share more like that... rebelmouse com


Absolutely fantastic posting! Lots of useful information and inspiration, both of which we all need!Relay appreciate your work. where to buy world's best head 2.0



I really thank you for the valuable info on this great subject and look forward to more great posts. Thanks a lot for enjoying this beauty article with me. I am appreciating it very much! Looking forward to another great article. Good luck to the author! All the best!
   <a href="http://www.rijmaran.be">verkoop caravans</a>


This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post. Rebelmouse



kusen aluminiumpintu aluminiumjendela aluminium