Home / Articles / News / Vote 2013 /  Xcel's claims on creating a municipal electric utility are wrong
. . . . . . .
Give Through iGivefirst
Thursday, October 31,2013

Xcel's claims on creating a municipal electric utility are wrong

By Mark Crisson

Xcel Energy contends that there is “simply no advantage to forming a utility in the way that Boulder is attempting.” This unsupported statement gives me pause and compels me to set the record straight.

The public power option is not new. Local communities have long had the right to own and operate their own electric utility or to grant a franchise to a private or investor-owned utility (IOU). The reason to do so varies. Many communities choose public power because they want lower rates, or better reliability, or improved service. This freedom to choose how electric service is provided is a local rights issue and a cornerstone of consumer protection.

Today, there are more than 2,000 public power utilities in the U.S., serving communities as small as Shelly, Minn., (with fewer than 100 customers) and as large as Los Angeles (with more than 1.4 million customers). Most public power utilities are owned by cities and towns, but some are owned by counties, public utility districts and states. Although different in size and location, they all have a common purpose: providing reliable and safe notfor-profit electricity, at the lowest reasonable price, while protecting our natural environment. They are rooted in the American tradition of neighbor helping neighbor to meet local needs.

At the heart of public power is local control — community stakeholders making policy decisions so that utility services are in tune with customers’ needs and values. In public power communities, decisions on vital services that affect every home and business are made through the local democratic process, at the ballot box, or by participation in city council and utility board meetings, public hearings and other public forums.

IOUs such as Xcel Energy generally oppose the formation of new public power utilities because, for them, it means the loss of customers and profits. New public power utilities also provide high-profile examples of what communities can do for themselves, and this may encourage other cities to form public power utilities.

For these reasons, IOUs often employ an array of tactics to fight the formation of new public power utilities. The most common tactic is to try to discredit public power and thereby create doubt and fear about alternatives to renewing their incumbent franchise. But in fact, public power has been so successful at its focused mission that it has earned the praise of industry analysts, the financial community and, most importantly, electric consumers.

In its recently released white paper, however, Xcel Energy criticizes Boulder’s efforts to municipalize in part by making false claims about the creation of a municipal utility in Winter Park, Fla. Xcel claims that the city’s cost to form a municipal utility soared past initial estimates, but the final cost to form the utility was exactly the same as estimates provided by the consultants hired to study the issue. One of Xcel’s claims is true — Winter Park’s rates are now higher than the investor-owned utility it replaced. There is a reason Winter Park’s rates are slightly higher — local control. Winter Park is a beautiful community with an extensive tree canopy, and the new utility’s consumer-owners have ordered their local utility to move all of the city’s overhead electric lines underground. The reason why the city bought the utility was to improve its reliability record, which was the worst in Florida. When Winter Park began operating the utility, reliability improved significantly. It costs money to place overhead lines underground, and the people of Winter Park have chosen to increase their rates 3.9 percent to improve their service.

On average, public power utilities have enjoyed a rate advantage over IOUs nationwide. For more than 50 years, data from the U.S. Department of Energy demonstrate that IOUs, on average, charge more for electricity than public power utilities. In 2010, residential customers of IOUs paid average rates that were 13 percent above those paid by customers of public power utilities. The people of Boulder should consider these facts as they explore forming a public power utility.

Crisson is president and chief executive officer of the American Public Power Association in Washington, D.C.

  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
No Registration Required

It is unfortunate that the Weekly is merely reprinting something that was in the Daily Camera already. The many flaws in this were addressed by people in comments when it was printed there, so I'd urge people to go read them here:





The greatest success of Ralph Lauren Longchamp Outlet is the creation of an ideal lifestyle www.truereligion-outlet.us.com encompassing disguised as a clothing brand Celine bags. Its label - Polo, Purple Label, Black Label, RLX, Coach Outlet preferably with a retail environment immersive Roger Vivier Shoes experience, and the commercial photographer Bruce True Religion Outlet Weber. Clothing is not better than the form - of Lifestyling not ideal, if you will UGG Outlet - pastures and yachts and football teams and shoppable michael kors outlet luxury Lauren was established worldwide.

However, the ideal way of life Coach Black Friday is an evolving concept. Now we find ourselves Oakley Outlet in the most unlikely places, often through Tiffany And Co Instagram (where Ralph Lauren has 940k Coach Factory Outlet followers and counting) and e-commerce Christian Louboutin Outlet fanatical streams, the platform is not the limitations of the physical space Christian Louboutin Shoes. Everything is a brand. Which is the brand, www.uggboots-blackfriday.com they are not particularly less than the actual brand. Tags are desirable Cheap UGG Boots as ever, but their world in a way more than our individual accounts, in accordance with the capture of the less lively world. Does this www.christianlouboutin-shoes.us.com leave Ralph Lauren?

Case Purple Label clothes True Religion Jeans have never looked better. Brown and haberdashery Day Cream michael kors handbags is a classic and timeless, even an old Ray Ban Sunglasses timey obviously collar flair mobile station Louis Vuitton Outlet Online seem exaggerated. Throughout, there is an emphasized texture, breathable fabrics, such as Coach Outlet silk and linen twill heavy feeling much lighter than it looks. Blue cut Moncler Jackets the strongest statements in bright blue tints French Louis Vuitton Outlet Stores breasted suit a wide peak lapels and a three-piece Roger Vivier Outlet lightweight denim, it looks more like a rich marine leaves are prominent. Violet sportswear brand selection can be presented as UGG Black Friday the biggest fight of Polo, including jacket Coach Outlet Store Online and trunks in French antique prints composition leather. From www.celine--handbags.us.com Safari, a Ralph Lauren typical, was given a slight twist Longchamp Handbags rendering black and tan. Black Label, the same delicate, made Europe take Purple Label ethics. Suit is light Tiffany Jewellery, soft and minimalist decoration.

BCBG dress polo Chalk, meanwhile, has not changed much over Moncler Outlet the years. He still layer clothing carefully dishevelment, twisting Celine Handbags her neck and wrists appearances perfect angle, and his mixed sports Coach Factory Outlet equipment Oxford and Portland. Baltic linked every American UGG Boots masculinity metaphor, it is childish and strong, nerds and jockish, preppy and rough. The real news Ray Ban here is that the guys in the Baltic will soon get a female company and women's polo shirts www.longchamp-outlet.us.com collection and Fifth Avenue flagship matching Tiffany Outlet is expected to launch this month.

Call lifestyle, Ralph Lauren has not disappeared, Louis Vuitton Outlet but we experience is changing. Shops Cheap Oakley Sunglasses and advertising, regardless of how they are the perfect Ray Ban Outlet style, they had no impact. The challenge of Ralph Lauren is to understand how to control our desire in this new world of multi-channel Chanel Outlet. We consume different because we see each other michael kors outlet and ourselves. Can you imagine a pioneer like Lauren relish the challenge. In fact Coach Outlet Store, Weber women polo combination just seems on paper, but it will be in the form of a series of life Chanel Handbags online videos. This could be a confirmation, polo spread smooth guy is not enough real, or at least can no longer be alone. It may still exist, but you will find not only in the mansion.