Find Local Events (pick a date)
 
Browse Boulder real estate by neighborhood, school and zip code along with other homes for sale in Colorado on COhomefinder.com

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
Home / Articles / Views / Danish Plan /  A costly inconvenient truth
. . . . . . .
Give Through iGivefirst
Thursday, June 26,2014

A costly inconvenient truth

By Paul Danish

Here’s an inconvenient little truth that keeps getting lost in the shuffle when local activists start hyper-ventillating about fracking: If you want to ban fracking, you may end up paying through the nose.

According to a story in the Denver Business Journal, a ban on fracking could cost Boulder County a bundle — a bundle of as much as $1 billion.

The $1 billion figure is not what the county would lose by foregoing taxes, royalties and the boost the local economy would get from oil and gas production. It is what Boulder County taxpayers would owe the holders of oil and gas mineral rights and oil and gas lease-holders in compensation for being denied access to their property.

The $1 billion figure is contained in a study done for the National Association of Royalty Owners by Netherland, Sewell and Associates, an international petroleum engineering firm, according to the Journal.

“The study looked at the money royalty owners might be missing out on due to a moratorium on drilling new oil and gas wells in Boulder County’s portion of the Wattenberg Field, one of the one of the richest oil and gas fields in the United States,” the paper said.

Boulder County currently has an 18-month moratorium in place on accepting new applications for oil and gas development, which will expire on January 1, 2015. If the moratorium turns into a permanent ban, the county mineral rights owners could sue on grounds that it constituted a “taking” of their property and demand compensation.

The study estimated that the moratorium is preventing the development of dozens of “sections” (one-square mile parcels of land) within Boulder County’s part of the Wattenberg Field. It claims that a royalty owner with a one-eighth interest in a single section could receive as much as $40 million in royalty payments over the productive life of a new well. Royalty owners with a one-fifth interest could receive as much as $64 million in royalty payments over the life of a new well.

“Figuring that there are at least 50 sections in the county that could be drilled and produced, the county could be on the hook for $1 billion in compensation for owners who want to develop their oil and gas minerals, but can’t,” the Journal said, citing the study.

An industry-funded study might well be high-balling the amount of compensation that mineral rights owners might be entitled to — the actual amount of compensation would be determined by a court — but the study’s figure does not seem implausible. A single well that produces 500,000 barrels of crude oil would yield roughly $50 million in revenue, assuming a price of $100 a barrel. Horizontal wells with multi-stage fracking that have estimated ultimate recoveries of 500,000 barrels or more are not uncommon in the Wattenberg Field, nor is it unusual to find half a dozen wells to a section.

But while the amount of compensation Boulder County could be on the hook for in the event it imposes a permanent ban on oil and gas production might be debatable, it is a near certainty that it would be on the hook for at least some compensation.

Mineral rights are a long-recognized property right, and in Colorado they can be bought, sold, and owned separately from surface property rights. Both the United States Constitution and the Colorado Constitution provide that private property can’t be taken without compensation.

If Boulder County or some of the cities in the county choose to ban oil and gas production, it is hard to see how they could avoid having to pay compensation to the people who own the mineral rights and have a legal right to produce those minerals — any more than the county could avoid paying compensation to the owners of surface property rights who might be banned from building on their land.

Boulder County and the major cities of Boulder County have spent hundreds of millions of dollars to buy and preserve open space — precisely because they cannot prevent all development on land unless a) they pay compensation to the owner for doing som or b) they own it. It is a near certainty that it will be the same with mineral rights. And given the current value of oil and gas, it is reasonable to assume that compensation for a county-wide ban on oil and gas production would cost the taxpayers at least as much as half a century of open space purchases have — and quite possibly more.

More than 95 percent of the oil and natural gas wells drilled in the United States are fracked. Without fracking, domestic oil and gas production would collapse within a few years. Voters who choose to vote to ban fracking are really voting to stop oil and gas production. There are a lot of Boulder County residents who may be cool with that, but they should realize going in that if they succeed in doing so, it is going to cost government and the taxpayers a bundle.

Respond: letters@boulderweekly.com 

This opinion column does not necessarily reflect the views of Boulder Weekly.

  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
POST A COMMENT
No Registration Required
REPLY TO THIS COMMENT

There you go again, Paul. In your dystopian world, mineral rights trump surface dweller rights to clean air, water and health. It's immoral, wrong and unsustainable. It's no different than war wherein by decree the "righteous" must act to restore democracy through force militarily or via legal action. The victims are counted along with the profits. Rights trampled are a cost of doing business while the folly and inane bluster are proffered as A costly inconvient truth.

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT

If Boulder County or some of the cities in the county choose to ban oil and gas production, it is hard to see why they should pay compensation to the people who own the banned "mineral rights" and produce those banned minerals.  If the government were to ban guns should the gun owners have to be compensated?   

 

If you would like travel but don't think you can pay for it, it is best to read with. You might get great travel refers to just a modest amount of research. find great travel deals

 

When a sales man should visit N cities in case each location is linked with the different city, then precisely what is the speediest path he / she should take as a way to minimize price tag of traveling? This document discusses this travelling gross sales man problem and applications. traveling sales

 

Thoroughly planned in addition to organized family vacation can possibly be real enjoyment and enjoyable and absolutely leaves you with good memories and this can be truly cherished with the rest your lives. Even so, with each of the fun in addition to excitement, organizing the ideal family traveling plan is usually a huge risk as well as a big liability. big family travels

 

Once you know that small business travel seriously isn't without it is risk along with the potential intended for crisis, then it is advisable to read this post. In this post we're going to talk around the management in addition to containment connected with crisis the way it relates to help travelers in addition to travel operators. impact travel

 

Some people are unclear around the travel marketplace. Travel agents can be considered the same as real estate brokers. Becoming some sort of travel agent and up specifically your dream house based traveling agent is usually an... thornton's travel

 

It truly is spring, and fresh man's nice turns which will get a completely new car. Well -- that will not be the suitable quote, although it's legitimate! But should you prefer a new drive, you need to receive a cheap insurance cover to defend it. cheap insurance plan

 

Dentist problems could potentially cause debilitating agony and extended damage. As long as they go unattended, they will even affect our overall health and with rare conditions, can possibly be life unhealthy. Therefore, obtaining insurance policies for dentist work is significant. alternative insurance

 

For anyone who is looking to modify to the car, you have to consider how it will eventually have an affect on your insurance quote likewise. A great deal of insurance companies should have reluctance with covering many modifications on account of an raise in possibility of both equally stealing in addition to possible breakdowns. modified cars insurance

 

There are various ideas revolving about the issue of a life insurance policy which usually are finally became myths. A big number of individuals in Toronto are likely to believe with these deceptive concepts which will cause a bit of coverage and then financial hardship towards people you attend to the almost all. toronto life insurance

 

World-wide-web progress, Shelley Lowery in addition to web-source. online. Is usually Shelley Lowery some sort of swindle or maybe is usually your lover authentic having authentic facts to help people on the net. web sourcing

 

Your house Small business Achievements Academy delivers teaching to help affiliate marketers. Is usually this system within the levels? We should carry a third party glimpse and discover. web academy

 

Paying for Koh Samui Property or home can be extremely difficult, in addition to if you learn just what exactly you will be accomplishing, you will probably find this obtaining practice for being both equally frustrating in addition to disheartening. Abide by your comprehensive guideline on how to order property or home with Koh Samui prior to carry of which exciting soar to the mysterious. samui property

 

Which has a sturdy wish workforce connected with knowledgeable authorities constantly in place is vital on your constant achievements to be a real estate investment individual. In this posting When i write about a lot more tactics with locating added customers on your workforce as a result of uncomplicated promotion approaches. dream estate

 

Personal research would be the personal record research of any unique corporation. The item means coming up with this security connected with dollars sweeping to the group or maybe this company. Authorities accomplish personal research with the help of quotients using studies. financial network analysis

 

Methodical is effective from the concepts connected with money in addition to credit ratings, using the options on the exploration target, usually are known for being many-sided in addition to many-leveled. fenton finance

 

Feeding on fresh doesn't just strengthen your overall health in addition to guide minimize indicators connected with inflammatory disorders (like asthma, osteoarthritis, fibromyalgia, for example. )#), although it will likewise keep cardiovascular system nutritious and in some cases keep a number of sorts of cancers. health cuisine

 

Do you like learning how to make simple your own wellness products with no more than this natural methods you have already in your residense and lawn? heal the healer

 

At this time there would seldom be a single person on the full planet who have not seen a minimum of one episode on the 1960's TELLY comedy "Get Clever. " Yes After all that bumbling Real estate agent 86 -- Maxwell Clever. get smart

 

If you're more dedicated that The movies stars manage to get their perfect happiness with uncomplicated whitening techniques, think all over again. A great deal of Hollywood personalities get every thing done into their bodies just by authorities. the perfect smile

 

The medical effects in addition to antioxidant pastime in blueberries along with fruit claimed in new studies usually are significant. Like for example , cancer, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, bothered brain functionality, and different age linked conditions. health research

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT

Hello!

Coach Outlet Store Online

Coach Outlet

Our Hearts Nearly Exploded While Rounding Up This Valentine's Day Cuteness For Kids

Coach Factory Outlet

Coach Factory

9 Celebrity Winter Looks You Can Get For Under $100: Taylor's Beanie, More

Coach Outlet Online

Coach Outlet Store Online

All We Have To Say Is Kristen Stewart's Cute Cropped Sweater Is Only $30

Coach Factory Online Sale

Coach Factory Outlet Online

14 Up-And-Coming Hot Hollywood Dudes You Need To Know

Coach Factory Outlet Store

Coach Factory Outlet

6 Brands With Awesome Black Leggings That Don't Turn See-Through After 1 Wash

Michael Kors Outlet 90% Off Sale

Michael Kors Outlet

Extra 10% Off Sale At Bluefly Comes Out To 45% Off Total-And They've Got Burberry

Red Bottoms Shoes

Red Bottoms Outlet

I want to call this bag rock-studded, but it's really more geode-studded, isn't it?

Michael Kors Outlet Online

Michael Kors Outlet

York City office from February 4-8, with the live auction set for 1 p.m. on February 9

Michael Kors Outlet

Michael Kors Outlet Online

Here's British model, and, by some reports, actress Amy Willerton, toting her Prada bag around Park City.

Louis Vuitton Outlet

Louis Vuitton Outlet Store

heading into a taping of Watch What Happens Live in NYC with a fully rockstudded Valentino satchel.

Coach Outlet Store Online

Coach Outlet

which seems most Kyra Sedgwick-appropriate.

Coach Outlet Store

Coach Outlet

Herschel Supply Co. Spring 2015 Coach Store Online

Coach Outlet

Coach Factory Outlet

Groundhog Day may not be an official holiday

Coach Outlet Factory Online

Coach Factory Outlet

Kylie and Kendall Jenner and Topshop? Now You're Talking

Coach Outlet Online

Coach Outlet Store Online

The New Spring Bags You'll Have Forever

Coach Handbags

Coach Outlet

3 Wedding Gowns From the Couture Shows-and 4 More Elie Saab Dresses You Could Totally Get Married In

Coach Factory Outlet

Coach Outlet

This Bar Saves Lives, a one-for-one firm that delivers food to children in need

Coach Factory

Coach Factory Outlet

Denmark at Hong Kong Fashion Week last Wednesday.

Coach Outlet

Coach Factory Outlet

Scared of Monday? Did you have that not in the pit of your stomach last night?

Coach Outlet Store

Coach Outlet

morning that in the second quarter, which ended Dec. 27, sales dropped 14 percent to $1.22 billion.

tiffany and co

tiffany Jewelry

Coach's new design concept have been significantly outperforming old locations.

Coach Factory Outlet

Coach Outlet

Coach's Sales Continue to Plummet, But the Relative Success of Its New Stores Offers Hope

Coach Outlet Store Online

Coach Outlet Online

Taken in a vacuum, Coach's sales numbers don't look too hot right now.

Coach Outlet

Coach Outlet Store Online

Coach CEO Victor Luis says its revamped stores are significantly outperforming the rest.

Coach Factory

Yes, I think I need these clogs to wear with lots of fair isle knits and vintage Edwardian blouses and woven leather belts!

Valentino Shoes

The transformation of Saint Valentine's Day over many years has turned this holiday into a massive marketing monster

Hermes Belts

Hermes Bag

Ousted American Apparel founder Dov Charney isn't ready to let go of the company, according to an article from today's

Kate Spade Outlet

Kate Spade Outlet Online

In addition to closing those stores, the company will also shutter the 12 locations of Jack Spade

Kate Spade Handbags

Kate Spade

Say goodbye to the affordable Kate Spade shop - The Cut

Kate Spade

Kate Spade Outlet

Say good-bye to Kate Spade Saturday's colorful, wallet-friendly offerings - as least as you know them now.

Kate Spade Outlet Online

Kate Spade Outlet

previously starred in a solo Chanel campaign.

Michael Kors Outlet Online

Michael Kors Outlet

While just about anything is better than staring at a pile of tangled cords.

Michael Kors Outlet

Michael Kors Outlet Online

New York-based section of the PurseBlog team spent the day at home with our laptops yesterday

Michael Kors

Michael Kors Outlet

this Zen Collection Cord Corral ($65) is downright lovely to look at.

Michael Kors Outlet

Michael Kors

which is much smoother and might wear better over the years?

Michael Kors Outlet Online Sale

Michael Kors Outlet

And right now this look just feels right.

Michael Kors Outlet Online

Michael Kors Outlet

you're probably aware that the Sundance Film Festival is taking place as we speak.

Outlet Michael Kors Online

Michael Kors

photos of bags around here. We review bags

Michael Kors Outlet 90% Off Sale

Michael Kors Outlet

make a final order (or two or three), so consider including this Floral Lazer Cut Skirt ($89).

Louis Vuitton Outlet Store

Louis Vuitton

Paris Fashion Week 2015: Chanel works its magic in Karl Lagerfeld hothouse

Louis Vuitton

Louis Vuitton Outlet

For the second time an Metiers d'Art show clashes with a major fashion event

Louis Vuitton Outlet Store

Louis Vuitton

4 Super Bowl Outfits for Every Type of Football Fan

Louis Vuitton Handbags

Louis Vuitton Outlet

Not Another One! Find Out Which Fashion Brand is Closing Its Doors Now

Louis Vuitton

Louis Vuitton Outlet

Here's a trend I can fully commit to!

Louis Vuitton Outlet

Louis Vuitton

official website. We offer Insurance, Savings, Investments & Retirement plans

Giuseppe Zanotti Shoes

Giuseppe Zanotti

Joe Zee Talks About The Least Glamorous Part Of His Job And Just Being A Badass Canuck

Chanel Handbags

Chanel bags

Moon tote and its audaciously architectural shape is striking and brilliant.

Coco Chanel Handbags

Chanel Handbags

the other from Chanel.I know what you all must be thinking

The North Face Outlet

The North Face

dorky heavy-heeled wooden clogs and sandals this season. This editorial styled by Geraldine Saglio from Vogue Paris's

North Face Outlet Online

North Face Outlet

Favorite Shoes: Manolo Blahnik BB Pumps

Hermes Bag

Hermes Handbags

Heritage Auctions Valentine's Day Luxury Handbag & Accessories Auction

Burberry Outlet Online

Burberry Handbags

The 6 Hottest Curly-Hair Color Trends Of 2015

Burberry Handbags

Burberry Outlet

Victoria Beckham is nothing if not a woman of impeccable taste, so, of course,

Co Co Chanel Handbags

Chanel Handbags

And right now this look just feels right.

Prada Outlet

Prada Handbags

Prada S.p.A. is an Italian luxury fashion house, specializing in ready-to-wear leather and fashion accessories, shoes, luggage.

Prada Handbags

Prada Outlet

Shay Mitchell & Her BFF Curated A Jewelry Collection For Capwell Co.

Prada Handbags Outlet

Prada Handbags

Sunglasses can give you instant James Dean cool, Audrey Hepburn glamour

Marc By Marc Jacobs

Marc Jacobs

is now also available for purchase on Zappos Couture.

Celine Handbags

Celine Outlet

In this week's edition of Snobgrams, Kelly lives the Cali life while Tina soaks up some rays and showcases a classic bag!

Ray-Ban Sunglasses

Cheap Ray-Ban Sunglasses

The corporate world has its fair share of pros and cons-there's the consistency of a set daily schedule

True Religion

True Religion Outlet

Khloe Kardashian at the Gym Leads Today's Star Sightings

Oakley Sunglasses

Cheap Oakley Sunglasses

It's morning. You've had your first cup of coffee, and you step out the door.

Ralph Lauren Outlet

Polo Ralph Lauren

Coco wants to meet, plus more fascinating celebrity Twitter posts and words of wisdom below.

tiffany and co

tiffany and co Jewelry

The World's No.1 Destination For Affordable Eyewear Get 15% Off Anything You Buy Today!

Ray-Ban Sunglasses

Cheap Ray-Ban Sunglasses

Women's Designer Sunglasses

Cheap Oakley Sunglasses

Oakley Sunglasses

The evolution of fringe has been one of fascination for me.

Oakley Vault

Oakley Sunglasses

so you can easily find a pair to flatter you. Free Shipping

Ray-Ban Outlet Store Online

Ray-Ban Outlet

Today's fashion news includes the cultural implications of the recent Men's Fashion Week...

Cheap Oakley Sunglasses

Oakley Sunglasses

Check out the entire selection of sunglasses on Amazon, including top styles from popular brands.

Abercrombie

Abercrombie And Fitch

Today's fashion news includes an interview with Karl about the latest Chanel collection...

Hollister Clothing Store

Hollister Clothing

Sunglasses - Name Brand Designer Shades & Sport Sunglasses from TOP BRANDS like Ray Ban

Cheap Oakley Sunglasses

Oakley Sunglasses

Flat Matte Reflective Revo Color Lens Large Horn Rimmed Style Sunglasses

Cheap Ray-Ban Sunglasses

Ray-Ban Sunglasses

This season's Firenze4Ever theme was Obsessions. As women

Abercrombie And Fitch

Luisa via Roma Firenze4Ever Style Lab, Part 3: Obsess to Impress

Abercrombie Clothes

The Pocket Change Shopping Blog is your one-stop

Toms Outlet

Timberland: The brand was founded by Nathan Swartz in 1973 and quickly became known for its durable

Celine Handbags

Ever since we started seeing some of our favorite celebrities like Beyonce and Cara Delevingne

Ray-Ban Sunglasses

Cheap Ray-Ban Sunglasses

Sunglasses are an essential tool in safeguarding the health of your eyes and the surrounding tissue.

Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet Online

Ralph Lauren Outlet

Would You Shop a Kendall and Kylie Jenner Topshop Collab?

Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet

The Shoes I'm Obsessed With For Spring: a moodboard

Tory Burch Outlet

and I am currently weighing my options. In years past I have loved my Swedish Hasbeens and Dr. Scholls

Tory Burch Shoes

Now Dreading: Kate Spade Saturday Is Closing Its Stores

Nike Air Jordan

How to Understand Football Like a Boss: ESPN's Sara Walsh Breaks it Down

Valentino Shoes

The latest round of Haute Couture shows has just concluded in Paris for Spring 2015

Toms Shoes Outlet Online

Toms Shoes

The Dreamiest Looks From the Paris Haute Couture Shows

True Religion Jeans

True Religion Outlet

We All Have Black Booties, Right? 25 Ways to Style Them

True Religion Outlet

True Religion

30 Outfits That'll Make You Want to Wear Black Ripped Jeans Every Day

True Religion Jeans

True Religion

See How Your Favorite Stars Bundled Up In Style at Sundance

Red Bottoms Shoes

I love my Classic Maxi to pieces and I'm always contemplating which large Chanel bag I should acquire next. Who said fancy had to be undersized? The beauty of a large bag is the standards it meets as an everyday bag, especially one you don't have to swap out on a daily basis. Selections from the Classic and Reissue Collections are Chanel enthusiast favorites, and they do tend to overshadow its just as fashionable handbag relatives.

 

 
Close
Close