BALTIMORE — Shaking, sweating and swooning are par
for the course among the passionate young fans of the “Twilight” series.
But reports that a scene in “Breaking Dawn” has been sparking seizures
in theaters nationwide has epilepsy experts on the alert and parents
thinking twice about letting their kids see the movie.
at the Maryland-based Epilepsy Foundation issued a warning this week to
their nearly 11,000 followers on Facebook, saying people prone to
certain types of seizures might want to skip the film, which has been
the top-grossing movie in the country for two weeks straight.
you were parents of a child with epilepsy, you would not send your
child to the movie,” says Mimi Carter, the foundation’s director of
communications. “Why would you risk it?”
have been at least nine reported instances of people suffering seizures
during “Breaking Dawn,” the latest installment in the teen vampire
series. The trigger seems to be a particularly intense birth scene that
involves a strobe effect with flashes of red, white and black light.
In one widely reported instance, a California man at the theater with his girlfriend began to convulse during the graphic scene.
to CBS Sacramento, paramedics rushed Brandon Gephart to the emergency
room after he was “convulsing, snorting, trying to breathe.” Gephart
remembered nothing of the attack, but his girlfriend, Kelly Bauman, told
reporters, “He scared me big time.”
instance, a woman who took her daughters to see the movie in Oregon
starting feeling “strange” during the birth scene.
“(s)tarted feeling sick to my stomach, like I was going to be sick,”
Tina Goss told television station KATU in Portland. “Really hot, really
sweaty, like on the verge of vomiting.”
reporters she wasn’t coherent again until arriving at a hospital. “My
hands were completely blue for like two to three hours,” she said. “The
next day, I was so lethargic I felt like I’d, you know, like ran eight
Other instances have been reported in Maine, Utah, Massachusetts and Canada.
more people say they have gotten sick during the movie — for reasons
that have nothing to do with epilepsy. On Twitter, for instance, dozens
of teens say they got queasy and even vomited or fainted during the
movie’s grislier interludes, which include a fair amount of blood and
A retired physician in California, Zach
Pine, began documenting cases on a website after his 18-year-old son,
who had never had a seizure, suffered one during the movie. He lists
nine reported instances on his Google page.
People susceptible to this sort of attack suffer from what’s known as photosensitivity, a stimulus-induced seizure disorder.
epilepsy is relatively uncommon in the population — about 3 million
Americans have it — photosensitivity is even rarer, occurring in just 3
percent of those with epilepsy.
According to Dr.
Tricia Ting, an assistant professor of neurology at University of
Maryland School of Medicine, people with this disorder often don’t
realize they have it until they suffer a seizure. “They may have gone
their whole lives without having a seizure, but in this circumstance,
when presented with a flickering light, it can induce their first
A seizure trigger for a photosensitive
person can be any number of things — strobe flashes as in the movie,
driving past a repetitive pattern like a picket fence, watching sunlight
flicker through some trees. And the seizure itself could be quite
noticeable, with convulsions, or undetectable, with a person simply
staring or seeming unresponsive.
triggers … an abnormal electrical discharge in the brain,” Ting says.
“That spark can lead to an electrical storm, which is a full seizure.”
Though “very upsetting and disturbing,” Ting says, these types of seizures are typically not life-threatening.
well-known instance of a photosensitive reaction happened in Japan in
1997, when nearly 700 children were hospitalized after suffering
seizures while watching the Pokemon cartoon on TV.
West’s video for “All of the Light” comes with a warning, saying it
could trigger seizures and that “viewer discretion is advised.”
The phenomenon has also been known to occur in people playing video games.
Solodar, a Newton, Mass., mother, began blogging and trying to raise
awareness about the problem after her daughter, Alice, suffered a
seizure while playing a game.
“It takes an event
like this ‘Twilight’ movie to get people to even consider the fact that
we have a public health problem that is much more extensive than people
realize,” she says.
Solodar said Alice, who is 18
now, had, like many teenagers, wanted to go see “Breaking Dawn,” but
doesn’t want to go now that she’s heard about the seizures. “She’d
rather not take any chances,” she said.
The film’s production company and American distributor, Summit Entertainment, declined to comment on the reported seizures.
Ting and epilepsy experts advise anyone prone to photosensitivity to
skip the film, they have some advice for those who go anyway and might
begin to feel ill.
“If people are seeing the film
and they start to feel funny, they can stop that by not continuing to
look at the screen,” Ting says, adding that closing one’s eyes might not
be enough. “They need to block it with their hands. You really have to
cover it completely.”
%uFFFD2011 The Baltimore Sun
Visit The Baltimore Sun at www.baltimoresun.com
Distributed by MCT Information Services