Not that long ago,
With its recent release of a completely revamped version of its mobile operating system,
The new software, dubbed Windows Phone 7 and debuting next month on three phones running on
network, is a huge improvement over its predecessor, Windows Mobile
6.5, and one of the most visually appealing mobile operating systems
out there. But it lacks key features, includes some frustrating user
interface elements and provides access to a far smaller selection of
applications than its most notable rivals, Apple’s iOS, which powers
the iPhone, and
In developing Windows Phone 7,
scrapped its old Windows Mobile software. That’s a good thing, because
Windows Mobile was ugly to look at and difficult to use. The new
Windows Phone 7 software, by contrast, is much sleeker and easier to
keeping much tighter control on Phone 7, limiting the number of
manufacturers to a handful of top-tier companies and dictating that
phones using the software meet certain minimum requirements, such as
having a touch-screen display with three system buttons underneath it
and a 5-megapixel camera.
Given the effort that
has put into revamping the interface for Windows Phone 7, its
insistence on uniformity is good. But it means that the new Windows
Phone 7 phones — I tested the Samsung Focus and the HTC Surround — are
almost interchangeable. The only significant difference between the
Focus and the Surround is that the Surround is somewhat thicker,
because it has a slide-up external speaker.
The home screen for Phone 7 has a series of tiles.
By tapping on a tile, you can launch a program or a “hub” where you can
find a group of similar programs, such as games. Other tiles are
dynamic; even without clicking on them, they can display helpful
information, such as upcoming appointments or recent updates posted by
friends on social networking sites.
Once you launch a program, there are other
differences from other smart phones. Windows Phone 7 uses clear
typography as titles for programs and hubs, so you always know what
program you are using. On the iPhone and Android, different screens
within particular programs are usually accessed by tapping small
virtual buttons or text links. In Windows Phone 7, by contrast, you
often have to simply swipe left or right to view different screens of
the program. This interface is very slick and works well.
Another compelling feature of Phone 7 is its
built-in support for Facebook. Once you sign in to Facebook, the
software will automatically link entries in your address book with
their corresponding Facebook profiles. Windows Phone 7 takes things a
step farther by linking its “Pictures” hub to Facebook also, allowing
you to access pictures your friends have posted on the social network
and view all the galleries you have uploaded to it.
Windows Phone 7 also provides a link to Xbox Live,
online gaming service that it developed for the Xbox game console. On
Windows Phone devices, Xbox Live will help connect users wanting to
play multiplayer games and will eventually allow phone users to play
games against Xbox gamers.
Despite these touches, there are lots of things
Windows Phone 7 lacks. It doesn’t support copy-and-paste. It doesn’t
offer an easy way to switch between open applications. And it doesn’t
have a universal search that allows you to find applications, content,
messages or other data stored on your device.
What’s more, its Web browser supports neither
Adobe’s Flash software nor HTML 5, which Apple has promoted as an
alternative to Flash. Without those technologies, Windows Phone 7
devices can’t display many of the videos or interactive Web sites that
you can access from the latest Android devices or the iPhone. It does
it’s working on many of these issues. Copy-and-paste are supposed to be
coming in an update early next year. And the company is working with
Adobe to develop a version of Flash for Windows Phone 7.
But the lack of such key features makes Phone 7 devices less useful than their Android and iPhone counterparts.
In some ways, the operating system, for all its
slickness, can also be more frustrating than its rivals. For example,
when you are using the Web browser and rotate the screen so that it’s
in landscape view, you lose all controls over the browsing experience.
Want to enter a new Web address or go to a bookmarked page? You have to
rotate the screen back to portrait view first.
The e-mail experience is similarly frustrating. Each
e-mail account you set up is represented by a new application tile.
There’s no way to access all your e-mail accounts by launching one
application — much less view the messages from all your accounts in one
But perhaps the biggest problem with Windows Phone 7
is the scant list of programs available for it. Yes, the system hasn’t
even launched yet, so maybe it’s not fair to criticize this. And some
of the most popular mobile apps, including Facebook, Twitter, YouTube
and Flight Control, are already available or soon will be.
But many, many more applications just aren’t
available on Windows Phone 7. Among the notable omissions: Pandora,
LinkedIn and “Angry Birds,” the hit iPhone game.
So Windows Phone 7 puts
WINDOWS PHONE 7
—Troy’s rating: 3.5 out of 5
—Likes: Sleek, easy-to-use, visually appealing
interface; dynamic application tiles show information without having to
launch apps; links to Facebook, Xbox Live and other social networks.
—Dislikes: Lacks key features such as
copy-and-paste, universal search and Flash; some features frustrating
to use; very few available apps.
(c) 2010, San Jose Mercury News (San Jose, Calif.).
Visit MercuryNews.com, the World Wide Web site of the
Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services.